Could Trump鈥檚 deregulation quest speed permitting in Canada too?

US president-elect Donald Trump made two picks for key posts in his administration last week that signal he鈥檚 serious about rolling back environmental regulations and speeding up permitting for oil and gas as well as mining projects 鈥 a policy that could put pressure on Canada to do the same.
Trump, who has repeatedly promised the US will 鈥渄rill baby, drill鈥 for fossil fuels, named Lee Zeldin, a former congressman from New York, as his pick on Nov. 11 to head up the Environmental Protection Agency. Zeldin has promised to roll back 鈥渓eft-wing鈥 regulations while also protecting the environment. He鈥檚 endorsed Trump鈥檚 call to use the EPA to pursue US 鈥渆nergy dominance鈥 and economic growth.
For Interior Secretary, a post that oversees the management and conservation of federal lands in the US, Trump announced Doug Burgum, governor of North Dakota 鈥 the third largest oil producing state in the country 鈥 as his choice. Burgum will also lead a newly created National Energy Council, which will focus on increasing US energy supplies by better coordinating federal agencies and adding capacity to the electricity grid.
Deregulation and speeding up permitting were key policies for Trump during his first term, and Frank Mariage, a mining-focused partner at law firm Fasken, says Trump鈥檚 picks show he considers that unfinished business.
Trump 2.0
鈥淲hen Trump 1.0 came in, he put in through executive orders a number of guidelines to start streamlining the permitting process. Most of those were repealed when Biden came in,鈥 Mariage says.
鈥淪o Trump is going to be looking to obviously put those back into force, and these nominations are a clear signal that that鈥檚 where they鈥檙e headed.鈥
While the focus of easing environmental regulations has been on fossil fuels, mining will also benefit, says Patricia Mohr, a former Scotiabank vice-president and economist. That will have spill-on effects in Canada, where permitting is not quite as slow as the United States, but still excruciating.
鈥淚f they do that south of the border, we鈥檙e going to have to finally speed up our permitting in Canada. Otherwise, we鈥檙e going to get left behind,鈥 says Mohr, who also sits on the board of Horizon Copper (TSXV: HCU) and is also the former editor of Capitalight Research鈥檚 critical minerals-focused newsletter.
鈥淚t鈥檚 going to create pressure on us because, in British Columbia alone, there are at least six late-stage mining projects that could actually be financed and get going. These are industrial mines, not gold mines. These things exist in BC, but they need to really be pushed by government to get going.鈥
Mohr admits some commodity prices aren鈥檛 cooperating 鈥 nickel for example 鈥 but says copper demand has held up despite weak growth in China, which accounts for over half of global demand.
The Prospectors & Developers Association of Canada (PDAC), which advocates for improvements to the regulatory framework, agrees reforms are sorely needed to capitalize on the nation鈥檚 mineral potential.
鈥淲hile there is uncertainty around potential policy changes in the US, any moves to streamline permitting there could further heighten competitive pressures on Canada,鈥 Jeff Killeen, PDAC鈥檚 director, policy and programs, said in an email to The Northern Miner. 鈥淲e believe changes are urgently needed, including harmonizing federal and provincial approvals to eliminate duplication, setting clear and predictable timelines for permitting, and ensuring regulatory bodies have the resources to manage applications efficiently.鈥
EV adoption
As Trump unveils his picks for key posts, much of the media focus has been on Trump鈥檚 support for fossil fuels, a reversal of Biden鈥檚 focus on fighting climate change and speeding the energy transition through the Inflation Reduction Act and other legislation. However, Trump also supports domestic production of critical minerals to reduce reliance on China, and has said that US copper and lithium production should be maximized.
Most analysts don鈥檛 see Trump repealing Biden鈥檚 Inflation Reduction Act as he鈥檚 promised, but he鈥檚 seen as likely to remove its incentives for electric vehicles. Mohr says such moves are likely to slow EV adoption in the US.
鈥淗owever, the adoption in the United States so far has been quite slow already, and so I don鈥檛 really think his policy will have that much impact,鈥 she said. 鈥淚 do think that it will be very difficult to slow the interest around the world in decarbonization, which means that you鈥檙e still going to have a lot of interest in renewable energy.鈥
Artificial intelligence
Trump says he wants to make the US a leader in artificial intelligence (AI), which is expected to require enormous amounts of power.
According to International Energy Agency figures, data centres, cryptocurrencies and AI consumed 460 terawatt hours of electricity in 2022. It projects that demand will more than double to 1,000 terawatt hours by 2026, just four years later.
Unlike EV enthusiasm and projected demand over the last several years, which has now deflated, taking lithium prices with it, Mohr says the expected power demands of AI aren鈥檛 being overhyped.
That means nuclear power, which tech giants Microsoft and Amazon are planning to tap to power their data centres, will be a winner under Trump. So will Canada鈥檚 uranium sector, which is the world鈥檚 second largest.
鈥淭he interest in the nuclear industry and in uranium has broad bipartisan support in the US Congress,鈥 Mohr said. 鈥淚鈥檓 not sure that it will be positively impacted by Mr. Trump鈥檚 presidency, but it won鈥檛 be negatively impacted.鈥
Tax impact
Mariage says Canada will also have to consider how to attract investment if Trump follows through with pledges to slash taxes.
鈥淭he extractive industry is very capital intense and it鈥檚 very risky, so everybody that鈥檚 in the business knows that high risk needs high reward.鈥
In Canada, the federal government鈥檚 sent contradictory signals on investment, with the capital gains tax hike this year working counter to its plans to boost critical minerals supply chain and manufacturing, announced in late 2022.
鈥淭hey鈥檙e 鈥榬ah rah鈥 on critical minerals but at the same time they鈥檙e making it harder for investment. At the same time, we鈥檙e talking about streamlining the permitting process, but we鈥檙e not necessarily doing anything about it.鈥
While the federal government has pushed hard on the manufacturing side of the critical minerals supply chain, granting billions in funding for new EV plants and battery manufacturing, it hasn鈥檛 done enough to ensure those plants can source supply locally, he said.
Based on Trump鈥檚 first term, when he placed duties on aluminum and steel that didn鈥檛 initially give Canada special treatment and reopened the North American Free Trade Agreement, Canada can鈥檛 necessarily count on special treatment on tariffs.
鈥淚鈥檇 like to think we have guaranteed co-operation, since they鈥檙e our biggest neighbour and 35 of the states in the US, their principal customer is Canada,鈥 Mariage said. 鈥淏ut let鈥檚 not forget what happened in Trump 1.0.鈥
With potentially radical changes coming to the US, mining powerhouse Canada will have to step up its game to keep that reputation.
鈥淭here鈥檚 going to be some pretty bold moves in the US for the extractive industry that will attract investment,鈥 Mariage says. 鈥淚f we don鈥檛 do the same, then people are going to be looking south of the border for investments instead of north of the border.鈥
{{ commodity.name }}
{{ post.title }}
{{ post.date }}
Comments